Tuesday, October 2, 2007

Indifference to Compassion

Well, I'm home sick today and trying to recover from a cold that I have had for two weeks now. It's been one of those colds I thought would just go away by taking some tylenol, but here I sit two weeks later with four medicines from the local "chemist", which include cough syrup, eye drops and a couple of pills for what is some type of conjunctivitis.

The following pictures are from my trip to Bangalore and Mysore in August. I never had an opportunity to show them to you, but this post is not really about this trip.


(These young boys were nice enough to accompany me up the 1,000 step, 45-minute hike up to the top of Mysore's highest nearby peak, Chamundi Hill. Three of them did it in sandles, the fourth barefoot.)

Other than that though, it's amazing to believe that it is nearing the end of my first year here in India. I am planning on staying into the coming year. Not sure if I'll be here for the entire year of 2008 or only for part of it, but I just have this feeling inside of me that I'm not done with India yet. I have a ton more to learn from the people and cultures of India and I think I have much more to give to these people.


(At the top, the boys took me to this nearby manmade pool. This man (who you can only see his big toe) was using the latest in fishing technology.)

Below are a couple of articles I thought you might find interesting. The first one talks about Delhi's "rag pickers" who are basically our garbage collectors. It's sad and disturbing, but it is a reality check. Many Delhites never consider what happens to the garbage once the woman collects it outside their door each morning or after they throw their garbage into the roadside bin each day. The fact is that there are thousands of people who go through the garbage each day who are not paid, but ask for donations from their neighborhoods. This is their manner of survival.

(Sri Chamundeswari Temple was at the top of Chamundi Hill)

Delhi Article: http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/27/world/asia/27ragpickers.html?_r=1&hp&oref=slogin


The second article details the madness of Mumbai. I think the most glaring difference between Mumbai and other major cities in developed countries (and mind you, I have yet to visit there) is that the horrible poverty of the city is not hidden, but often times sits adjacent to some of the nicest hotels, resorts, cinemas and restaurants.

(I think I caught this cow right as it was being blessed from up above or about to be zapped into space.)

(And I did do some work while in Bangalore. I met with many of my colleagues at CII's first Centre of Excellence, the Institute of Quality.)

Josh's editorial: This is possible because many Indians still do not see a problem with the poverty of the country. It's a concept that difficult to understand for most Westerners and even more difficult when you are here and see it right in front of you. However, the reality is that this society has not evolved to a point yet where there is great concern for one's community or for others outside your tight, communal circle.

I will forever remember what one Indian CEO of a well-respected, international foundation told me early on in my time here. He said approximately, "Josh, the fact is that nothing is going to change in India until your average Indian sees the impoverished family, with malnourished, naked children begging on the sidewalk in the middle of the city, and thinks this is wrong and should not be happening in my country. Instead, most Indians think, 'at least my children are better off than theirs.' "

Of course, this is changing - slowly - throughout India. As the country becomes more interconnected with the world, as India compares itself more with other world powers, as pressure from the next generation of Indians demands more from its country, as the hierarchy and entrenched caste system of India lessens, hopefully this indifference to the suffering of their own neighbors will transform to compassion.

Mumbai Article: http://travel.nytimes.com/2007/09/23/travel/tmagazine/10well-mumbai-t.html?hp

3 comments:

a.n.g.e.l.a. said...

enjoyed the post. thanks for sharing with us

Unknown said...

Josh:

In my opinion, you have struck the nail on its head in your blog "compassion..." India's poverty is of its own making and has nothing to do with so-called exploitation by the Western countries. Also, the well-known ideas about "spirituality" of India is mostly a myth. The only extra bit is that the poor are actually even more selfish--when given a chance they are worse exploiters!

I hope your insight does not fade away under the popular public opinion.

Jayant
Vancouver

disha said...

hey josh, i guess dat CEO very smartly addressed 1 of the cause of existence of poverty in india.....by nw u must b very well verse wid the indian attitude or mentality towardzs every social,political ,economical or releigious issues.....we can just take up these problems as a discussion topic or a tea-time or may be a supper time gossips....today i m more upset after knowing the fact that many of the popular NGOs also are nt working positively for the issues they address.......i m jst a graduate n wanted 2 join up sum gud NGO bt this what i got to hear from sum of the people who themselves have been part of such an organisation..........i very much believe in idea of EACH 1 TEACH 1 n hv been trying to practice it 4 last 1 or 2 yrs....n gs this is hw v can gt the desired results........nyways thankx a lot for sharing ur views